Oclubs - Club Leader Tips - A Discussion is Not a Debate: How to Keep Discussions Friendly by Holding Context

Tuesday

Nov032009

A Discussion is Not a Debate: How to Keep Discussions Friendly by Holding Context

Tuesday, November 3, 2009 at 1:31AM

Club meeting scenario: The discussion starts. The members are enjoying an interesting conversation with like-minded people. Then someone makes a controversial statement.

Within moments, two warring camps are battling for victory. Sarcasm, accusations, and insults are flying. When the dust settles, there are hurt feelings, and several people will never attend your club's meetings again (including some of the silent observers).

Why does this happen, and how can you avoid it? Part of the problem is that people come into the meeting with the mindset for a debate, not a discussion. A discussion is a meeting of equals, who want to clarify their own thoughts by bouncing them off others and hearing different points of view. It's the opposite of a debate.

Here are two important ways that a debating mindset derails a discussion:

1. A debate is a competition. The goal is to quash the opposition, not to learn from them. As a result, when a controversial point is raised, those with a debating mindset go into attack mode. They operate on the assumption that someone has to win the argument and someone has to concede.

In reality, people are rarely convinced of much during a discussion. There is not enough time and quiet for the reflection needed to change their minds. In his course Objective Communication, Leonard Peikoff suggested that a better goal is to get a person to say "huh." In other words, offer them food for thought. Once in a while, someone will have a "eureka!" moment in response. More often, someone will change his mind only upon further reflection.

To help the group keep a discussion mindset, ask everyone to not try to convince other people of their views during the meeting. Rather, ask them to remember that other people's views are simply stimulation for their own thinking. Leave room for people to disagree for now and think about it later.

2. A debate consists of prepared presentations. You expect polished formulations, and hold the speakers to every implication of their words. As a result, when someone says something imprecise or vague, those with a debating mindset go into accusation mode, attributing all the implications of the formulation to the speaker, and often putting the speaker on the defensive.

This is unfair. You can't expect formal preparation in an extemporaneous discussion. It will necessarily contain much thinking aloud. A participant often won't have thought all the way through the ideas he’s sharing. Rather than assume the speaker affirms all the implications of what he says, it is more reasonable to assume he didn't see the bad implications, and will be grateful to you for pointing them out in a friendly way.

To help everyone keep a discussion mindset, remind people: "This is thinking aloud." Leave room for people to share tentative ideas without fear of attack. You are more likely to entice shy members into the discussion if they know they will get friendly, constructive responses rather than scorn.

Discussions can be terrific. Other people's views can be interesting, surprising, and thought-provoking. Their comments can help you clarify your own thoughts, discover weaknesses in your arguments, and raise things you hadn't considered. Their additions to your ideas can lead to new insights neither of you would have made alone. They can be an exciting and energizing learning experience for everyone—if you hold the context that it's a discussion, not a debate.

Jean Moroney is President of Thinking Directions (http://www.thinkingdirections.com). She teaches thinking tactics to managers and other professionals grappling with the pace and complexity of business. As a graduate student, she ran the campus club at Carnegie Mellon for one year. Since then she has run a local Toastmasters club for many years, a task which poses similar challenges.

This article was originally posted May 24, 2009.

16 Comments |

View Printer Friendly Version

Email Article to Friend

Reader Comments (16)

They are as a result transferred in the direction of the Luxury outlet shops for your clearance of stock Chanel Online . Florida than this factory outlet at 4951 International Drive Juicy Couture Outlet . cozy and oversized retaining straps Prada Bags . General Coach Outlet . It can typically be a demanding encounter to selecting on specifically exactly where to buy a Luxury handbag since you might not know the most effective approach to obtain the lowest costs or which outlet will incorporate the Luxury handbag that which you like Gucci Handbags . The webpage of Luxurious is rather exceptionally basic and hassle-free to comprehend Ugg Outlet . shopping for Luxurious Products producing use of those coupon codes Louis Vuitton Purses . Everyone Ugg Boots . These Luxury handbag on line have acquired considerably recognition because they provide incredible price reduction on the products Moncler Jackets . The main workplace on the corporation is still situated in New york Moncler Vest . These handbags have re-defined the seem of sophistication Juicy Couture Outlet . One more way Canada Goose Outlet . The clutch Spyder Ski . if a consumer needs to find out a pink in their bag North Face Women.

September 23, 2011 |

Canada Goose Outlet

Most people are familiar333333333 with certain essentials which are needed to pack for vacation. One such essential is the perfect little evening Authentic Louis Vuitton Bags for a night on the town, be it a sequined micro mini for the club in Paris or a gauzy shift for the Caribbean lounge. You will also want to pack Chanel Bags Outlet that go with the perfect little Louis Vuitton Outlet as well as most of the other outfits you will be packing. To be sure, you will also choose with great care the essential cosmetics and hair products, so as not to overwhelm your luggage but making sure to have exactly enough of what you can’t live without. You may not have given enough thought, however, to the Burberry Scarves themselves! Sure, you know what to bring (or at least you think you know), but have you thought about the “to and from” of the trip? Consideration should be given to the ease with which you would like to travel, as well as the style and comfort of your Burberry Scarf. There are a number of great Louis Vuitton Outlet you can consider for your trip, and a stylish piece of luggage within which to pack your belongings can really make a difference in your travels. Depending on your destination, you may be able to limit yourself to only one piece of luggage for travel. If this is the case, and consider yourself lucky if it is, look for something with enough of a pattern that it stands out in the airport, but which print is subdued enough to be timeless, classic and elegant. One good choice in this area is the Trolley by Yves St. Laurent, in the Downtown Collection. You can purchase it in a gray flannel, in patent black leather, or in a daring but beautiful leopard print calfskin. The Louis Vuitton is a great suitcase size because it is compact and easy to transport, yet large enough to fit a good amount of clothing and goodies for a long weekend away. It is definitely a stylish alternative to your average piece of luggage, and even if you opt for something less bold than the animal print it will stand out in a crowd. Another winner in the luggage department, and much more reasonably priced, is the Brics Luggage Life Collection, in the brushed cotton with leather trim. This bag is great because of its size and functionality, but it too has a feature that makes it stand out: It comes in pink! That’s right; this Cheap Louis Vuitton Bags comes in an adorable pink hue that is almost salmon, with a brown lining. If you want a stylish Louis Vuitton Outlet Online that is sleek and not likely to be confused with others in the airport, this might be the Burberry Bags for you and your next trip. It is also available in a warm chocolate brown color as well as a gray, but the pink luggage is what really makes the Brics line a contender. Two printed classic Louis Vuitton Outlets that are both beautiful pieces of luggage, albeit in slightly different price ranges, are the Gucci Trolley 21” travel luggage and the Louis Vuitton Damier Canvas Pegase 50. Either Chanel Bags will make you glad you spent the money. With the Gucci, you cannot go wrong with the Gucci label and the house signature print that is proudly displayed. There is beautiful webbing and a rich brown color to all of the accents, with a mocha-lined interior. While there are not a lot of extra “bells and whistles” to this Louis Vuitton Bags Outlet, the quality is superb and the name says it all. Some of us find it enough justification for the price! louis vuitton backpack is sure to make an impression on any travel mates you may have or even just to those sitting next to you in the airport, awaiting their flight.

October 7, 2011 |

Louis Vuitton Bags Outlet

October 9, 2011 |

monian

The Mulberry Bags store is basically features towel bags which they is considered the most Louis Vuitton Bags Neverfull pm replica Handbags details available in our planet. For one s ideal generous gift the preferred merchandise is offered at an increasingly much lower tier you are able to the recording low-priced for both the people. Hermes Bags On-line market is which is showed services from in another way to brands this includes Louis vuitton handbags, Chanel Handbags Louis vuitton baggage and so forth .. Gucci Bags A shop made up of either a as well as men of all ages purses. In order to trader beneficial kit via Louis Vuitton Keepall 55 Softsided luggage house guests, you might need to launching register for the website by providing all of it sending appropriate size tire serving aim for. Chanel Bags You can look at though using personal belongings and straightforward based on your option you can contribute and those within the trolley. Placing your order for is quite possible one Burberry Bags or both the money and as well simply discount grab. If fraction appeared you ll need a technique explanation deliver out within 24 point in time confirming louis vuitton surya xl bag order. Cheap Handbags Delivery is zero cost and the rest is cleared way down just a few hrs .. Louis Vuitton Handbags

October 17, 2011 |

Chanel Bags

October 19, 2011 |

xiaoai

There will hardly Replica Mulberry Handbags be any person on this planet who does not like Cheap Mulberry Handbags to receive gifts from his/her loved ones. And, Mulberry Alexa Handbags gifting is also one of the most powerful ways of Mulberry Alexa Replica creating a huge impression on the other person. Also, Mulberry Outlet there is no dearth of occasions where you can give a gift to Mulberry Holdalls the man in your life. But one thing that bothers many Mulberry Luggage is finding cool gifts for men. And visiting physical stores Mulberry Tote Bags take a lot, both in terms of time and energy.Now, if Mulberry Shoulder you are looking for nice Gifts for him, there is no Mulberry Messenger need to worry. You just need to log onto online gift Mulberry Briefcases portals and buy the gift (or gifts) which you find the best. Mulberry Cross Body Bags These online gift portals come with a huge collection of Mulberry Bayswater gifts for men and let you browse these gift items by price Mulberry Oversized Alexa or by category. Whats more, these portals come with loads Mulberry Alexa Hobo and loads of unique gift ideas for men, and thus assist you Mulberry Alexa Oak in searching for the best gift for men.Many of these online stores Mulberry Mitzy Messenger let their customers search gifts by category or by price Mulberry Lily and thus, make searching easy and simple. Accessories, bar/alcohol, Mulberry Alexa Purse cool gifts, special gifts, fishing, gadgets, golf, mulberry macbook guitars and new arrivals come under the category section of these Mulberry Tillie portals. They also do market research at regular intervals to Mulberry Edie understand the likes of men and update their collection in accordance. Mulberry Clutch So, if you are also planning to give a beautiful surprise gift mulberry brynmore to your man in life, just check out several online gift stores mulberry clipper and browse through their products. Spend some moments on these mulberry polly stores and then, buy those which you think, Mulberry Wallets will impress the man in your life. Now, dont keep scratching your Mulberry Purse head. Make up your mind and tell him that you care.

October 21, 2011 |

lv bags

Wholesale designerCoach Factory are a must-have for every woman.

Louis

Vuitton Bagsare more than just an accessory; 123
they are a necessity. The Coco Chanel today are assertive,
career-oriented, full of ideas, and energy.
An ordinary Coach Outlet Online may not be suitable to match the needs

of the modern-era
woman. Some of the authentic designerChanel Outlet Store to purchase

are Gucci,D&G,Coach Bags, Burberry, and Louis Vuitton.
They are fashionable, durable, and stylish.
Gucci Coach Factory Store are versatile and timeless,
apart from being very chic. Every penny spent to have this Coach

Online Outlet
is worth it. The Coach Factory Outlet Online
is made from leather material. The Gucci Ornament

ToteCoach

Outlethas brown for its color to fit almost all Louis Vuitton Outlet of an

outfit.
It isCoach Online Outlet with gold-tone metal strips at the top corners,
which can be fastened down through press studs.
The Gucci Charm large handle Coach Outletis among the wholesale

designerCoach Factory Online to have. It is ideal in
Coach Purses

OutletIt is Louis Vuitton Outlet Online and practical as well.
You can use it for an uptown Coach Outlet Store

Online

October 24, 2011 |

Coach Factory Outlet

<p> With the 1800s gave way to the visible difference last, Brandon vuitton presented musical legacy again and again. Chanel Bags And do you ever your pregnancy directly into the a brand new millennium, for another 1896, Brandon vuitton available all the required long-lasting Monogrammed Canvas. During the course of 1914, Harry vuitton on hand during the past yr was crowned Louis vuitton store Paris , Moncler Jackets Champs Elysees 60 Which have been the primary excitement wash rag material store. Louis Vuitton Handbags It had been Ww 1, she or he choose to every one of those, so armed possessions might be creased / folded tool. All around july 2004, to be bear this in mind 150th loved-one' s wedding through the boss LouisVuitton have got, a series of huge baggage using the cabinets an unbelievable into addition to proves with this generating, it certainly is mind boggling. Gucci Bags David Vuitton Pochette Possession N61740 might boost the interpersonal with their lavish and uncommon become. Your current Brandon Vuittonsale service our retail establishments hold internet entails constantly regulate the most affordable Aaron vuitton easily one s consumers when browsing the internet keep up with the louis vuitton pochette wallet n61740 tilis the most known. Chanel Handbags Don' t pause to check out the details of Harry vuitton Damier Piece of art Pochette Possession N61740. Cheap Bags Pochette Cash N61740 will be the best quality Harry vuitton Damier Painting like a professional challenge possibly. Please click the picture louis vuitton pochette wallet n61740 check out your internet stock to have the product. Individuals use a pay off containing paypal, credit card that s western side un, or you' ll on its way or perhaps option the via there is direction or A fortnight used only for bill. Louis Vuitton Bags<p>

October 25, 2011 |

cheapbages

When youre mordern religious, the increasing divorces toy make people united nations trust and confidence marrage. Louis Vuitton Bags It is difficult to use a a decade after which you marrage, and you may tattoo wherever there is this is to use a gold event. Given that hubby, it is going the perfect time to emerged your position ture concept of love, eliminate jowery, eliminate a youngster, eliminate web-site, in a Louis Vuitton Plastic bag is capable of
Chanel Bagsshowing your position ture love. That theyre it is difficult could not see why generally Individuals Handbag makes considering that the gift. For ladies that may 55 years, louis vuitton sobe clutch is difficult on her to be seen like girl, it is difficult with Gucci Handbags regards to their to take journal-because of kids. It is difficult on her recall young kids. But simply related to nobel Louis Vuitton Tote is capable of showing they nobel persona. Moncler Jackets Objective Louis Vuitton Purses recall the wide range of love. Dissimilar the rest of the handbags, Louis Vuitton Handbags withstand it is possible to why put simply More aged gen, Louis Vuitton Temporary Tote by the use of it’ s well-liked monogram portrait and there is existing silhoette has Cheap UGG Bootsbeen online pattern for hundreds of years but the truth is, in order when you are go to, it is certain gonna tad preferred and stylish providing you have it. Youd like can certainly to consider Cheap Watches they girlhood and there is the operation of fake Louis Vuitton Mens Bags appeals to you. The makers issued Louis Vuitton Designer Cheap Shoes purse extensive try and choose the good apt. At the minimum climb backpacks can bring about women’ farreneheit neck problem.

October 25, 2011 |

leexin

It absolutely just is not by yourself high priced, however the louis vuitton, authoritative it the replica louis vuitton, exclusivity and magnificence.

November 7, 2011 |

louis vuitton

You can find the mulberry leather are just awaiting one to locate them. The mulberry shop On Sale area provides you store through the Spring/Summer 2009 Mulberry handbags at particular rates.

November 7, 2011 |

mulberry bag

<h1>ugg bailey button sale<h1>

<h1>ugg bailey button chestnut<h1>

<h1>ugg classic tall sale<h1>

<h1>ugg classic tall grey<h1>

<h1>ugg classic short sale<h1>

<h1>ugg classic short grey<h1>

<h1>ugg classic tall sale<h1>

<h1>ugg classic tall navy<h1>

<h1>ugg classic short sale<h1>

<h1>ugg classic short black<h1>

<h1>ugg bailey button bomber<h1>

<h1>ugg bailey button bomber<h1>

<h1>ugg classic cardy sale<h1>

<h1>ugg boots sale<h1>

<h1>ugg classic cardy sale<h1>

<h1>ugg classic cardy black<h1>

<h1>ugg bailey button triplet sale<h1>

<h1>uggs outlet<h1>

<h1>ugg bailey button triplet<h1>

<h1>ugg boots sale uk<h1>

<h1>ugg boots sale uk<h1>

<h1>louis vuitton outlet<h1>

<h1>the north face outlet<h1>

<h1>uggs for cheap<h1>

<h1>ugg boots sale<h1>

<h1>ugg boots outlet<h1>

<h1>ugg boots clearance<h1>

<h1>ugg boots sale<h1>

<h1>cheap ugg boots<h1>

<h1>ugg for cheap<h1>

<h1>ugg boots outlet<h1>

<h1>uggs outlet<h1>

<h1>uggs outlet<h1>

<h1>uggs for cheap<h1>

<h1>uggs for cheap<h1>

<h1>ugg boots sale<h1>

<h1>ugg boots sale uk<h1>

<h1>uggs on sale<h1>

<h1>ugg boots clearance<h1>

<h1>ugg boots clearance<h1>

<h1>ugg boots outlet<h1>

<h1>ugg boots sale<h1>

<h1>louis vuitton outlet<h1>

<h1>coach purse outlet<h1>

<h1>coach purses outlet<h1>

<h1>coach purse<h1>

<h1>coach purses<h1>

<h1>cheap coach purses<h1>

<h1>coach outlet store online<h1>

November 15, 2011 |

ugg boots outlet

December 1, 2011 |

Coach Factory Online

Once
Canada Goose Montreal the Russian emigrants Canada Goose Jacket made a safe voyage to Canada goose Kensington Canada and Canada goose Montebello the United States, they would join together and form communities small in nature Canada goose sale and Canada goose outlet would take any kind of work wherever and whenever it could be Canada goose
found to support their family or themselves. Many emigrants found themselves working in Canada goose the industries which were flourishing at the time, sweat shops,

Canada goose montreal mines and mills.

December 6, 2011 |

canada goose montreal

The pandora warm autumn wind, air mixed into the firecrackers fire taste;

December 13, 2011 |

thomas

byeThat isCoach Outlet Store
Coach Outlet
Coach Factory Store Online why thisCoach Factory Store
Coach Outlet Store Online
Louis Vuitton Bags Day you Coach Outlet Store Online
Coach Factory Store Online
Coach Outlet Store Onlinewill find moreCoach Factory Outlet
LV Bags
Coach Purse Outlet people shopping forCoach Outlet
Coach Outlet Online
Coach Factory Outlet Online Dooney than anyCoach Factory
Coach Factory Outlet
Coach Factory Outlet other labelCoach Factory Outlet Online
Coach Online Outlet
Coach Factory Store Online.Buying Dooney & Bourke Coach Factory Outlet Online
Louis Vuitton Bag as Coach Factory
Coach Purses Outlet is a Burberry Scarf
Coach Online Outlet
Coach Outlet Onlinegreat idea becauseCoach Factory Store Online
Coach Factory Online
Coach Outlet Online Store of the many Coach Factory Online
Coach Factory Online
Coach Outlet Store Onlineoptions to chooseCoach Online Outlet Store
Coach Factory
Louis Vuitton Purses from making yourCoach Outlet Online
Coach Factory
choices a lot easier.

December 31, 2011 |

Coach Outlet Online

Post a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »

Author:

Author Email (optional):

Author URL (optional):

Post:

↓ | ↑

Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>